第六十三輯.第三期 - 2017-09-30


A Critical Review of the Policies of Academic Dismissal from University

作 者:
何萬順、林俊儒 / One-Soon, Her、Jun-Ru, Lin
學業退學、釋字563號、大學自治、合理妥適、學業成就 / academic dismissal, Judicial Yuan Interpretation No. 563, university autonomy, reasonable and appropriate, academic achievements
  • 摘要
  • 英文摘要
  • 參考文獻
  • 全文下載
Judicial Yuan Interpretation No. 563 has made clear that the policies of academic dismissal from university are within the rights of university autonomy. However, as such policies do violate students’ right to education, the Constitutional Court requires these policies be ‘reasonable and appropriate’ and their making and implementation follow ‘due process of law’. Based on these requirements, this paper examines the rules of academic dismissal implemented by three of the top universities in Taiwan, namely, National Taiwan University, National Chengchi University, and National Tsing Hua University, and demonstrates that, due to the logical flaws in their basic design and assumptions, these rules are far from being ‘reasonable or appropriate’, and are therefore likely to be judged as problematic in court. We further argue that the enforcement of these rules, which have been made less and less stringent in recent years, not only fails to serve the purpose of upholding the standard of student academic performance, but also constitutes a form of maltreatment and persecution of disadvantaged students. We then discuss the misguided values and beliefs underlying such policies. This paper thus concludes that the current policies should be abolished and replaced with more constructive measures.


[Wang, S-K; Huang, J-J (2010). The application of self-determination theory on students’ career choice and learning outcomes under the multiple college admission system. Journal of Research in Education Sciences55(2), 1-27.]


[Wang, C-Z; Pan, W-Y (2006). A survey of life stress and coping strategy of colleges students. Chia Nan Annual Bulletin32, 469-483]


[Zhu, Z-K;Ye, Z-Y (2011/11/25). The tears of a female student bringing down the academic dismissal policy at National Taiwan Normanl University. China Times]

朱慧萍、饒夢霞(2000)。大學轉變科系學生生涯決定歷程。教育心理學報, 32(1),41-65。

[Chu H-P, Rau M-S (2000). A Qualitative Research of Career Decision Making Process of CollegeStudents Who Changed Their Majors, Bulletin of Educational Psychology32(1), 41-65.]


[Her, O-S; Liao, Y-H; Chiang K-H (2014). On the Legality of Taiwan Universities' English Graduation Benchmark Enforcement Rules: A Case Study of National Chengchi University. Chengchi Law Review139, 1-64.]


[Lee, J-T (1998/9/15) Why should Providence University be more strict. United Daily News supplement.]


[Lee, H-Z (2014). The administrative law of education. Taipei, Taiwan: Angle.]


[Shen, Y-R (2014/6/15). No increase of students failing courses after the canceling of academic dismissal at National Taiwan Normanl University. UDN.com.]


[Lin, M-C (2001). University Self-Administration and The Principle of Legal Reservation –Highest Administrative Court Verdict No.1833 "Year 89 Suit Tzu" as a Core Research (The case of Academic Dismissal from Shih Hsin University). The Taiwan Law Review77, 162-170.]


[Hu C-H (2011/11/25). The first among top universities: Taiwan Normal University abolishing academic dismissal. Liberty Times.]


[Hong, B-L (2001). The study on the element of academic learning impact in college students. Journal of General Education3, 7-27.]


[Hsu M-C (2011). On the issues concering the ‘two-one’ academic dismissal. National Policy Forum1(8), 164-169]

陳智華(2015,9月8日)。二一退學鬆綁 快成歷史名詞。聯合新聞網

[Chen C-H (2015/9/8).The ‘two-one’ academic dismissal soon to be history. UDN.com.]


[Hsu, C-Z (2008). A Study on the Institution of Expulsion from the Essence of University Self-Administration also Comment on Judicial Yuan Interpretation No.563. Thought and Words: Journal of the Humanities and Social Science46(4), 105-174.]


[Hsu, Y-L(2016). The analyzation of aboriginal education in 104 semester. The bureau of Statistics in the ministery of Education. Retrieved from http://stats.moe.gov.tw/files/analysis/104native.pdf ]


[Hsu ,Y-T (2013). Legal state and educational administration: Educational Law of self-fulfillment (2nd edition). Taipei, Taiwan: Angle.]


[Tseng Y-F (1998/10/27). Universities’ academic dismissal policies vary greatly. Central Daily News.]

馮靖惠(2017,5月2日)。教部擬推開放式大學 免筆試、無年限、有學位。聯合新聞網

[Feng, J-H (2017/5/2). Ministry of education will adress the Open University without written test and fixed year. UDN.com.]


[Hung, Z-Y (2002). The constituional issues on Academic Dismissal. The Volume of thesisto express birthday good wishes to Prof. Yih-nan Liaw: The economic law construction and challenges on New century, 81-125. Taipei, Taiwan: Angle.]


[Hung, J-T., & Zhang, W-Z (2011). The principle of university autonomy and two kinds of principle of legal reservation- On Judicial Yuan No. 563, 626 and 684. The Law Monthly, 62(6), 13-30.]


[Huan, Y-N (2003). A probe into university autonomy, dismissal from university, preservation principle and percentage principle of law--Highest Administrative Court Verdict No.344 "Year 91 Pan Tzu" and No.467 "Year 91 Pan Tzu" as a core research and a commentary on Grand Justice's Exploitation No. 563 "Shi Tzu" of The Judiciary. The Journal of Social Studies Education Research8, 197-222.]


[Yang, M-L (2005). The value of educational achievement and adolescents' mental Health. Formosa Journal of Mental Health18(2), 75-99.]


[Pan, C-D (1996). A study of the relationships among personality trait, adjustment, and achievement of university freshmen. Chung Yuan Journal24(2), 35-51.]

鄭語謙(2016,12月9日)。大學原住民退學率是一般生2倍 多因經濟休學。聯合新聞網

[Zheng, Y-Q (2016/12/9). The rate of dimissal of aboriginal students from universities is twice that of other students, due mostlt to financial reasons. UDN.com.]


[Wei, C-F., & Hung, I-Z (2011). A Longitudinal study on the sequence of cause and effect between academic achievement and mental health: Using data from the TEPS. Formosa Journal of Mental Health24(1), 97-130.]

嚴文廷(2011,11月24日)。全台唯一 台師大將廢除退學制度。聯合晚報

[Yan W-T (2011/11/24). Taiwan Normal University soon to be the only university to abolish academic dismissal. United Evening News.]


[Tan J-S (2009). On judicial review of the actions of academic dismissal, from the perspective of academic reasons, Journal of Hunan University23(4), 121-125.]


[Su,Y-I (2013). A study on the "Multi-Star Project" of the university entrance system and adjustment of students entering universities through this project in Taiwan (Unpublished master’s thesis). Tamkang University, New Taipei City, Taiwan.]

Atiq, E. H (2014). Why motives matter: Reframing the crowding out effect of legal incentives. The Yale Law Journal123(4), 1070–1116.

Barbara L. McCombs (2000). Reducing the achievement gap. Society37(5), 29-39.

Carole A. Ames (1990). Motivation: What teachers need to know. Teachers College Record, 91, 409-421.

Manwani, Srivastava, Saxena (1981). Study habit, adjustment and anxiety among Scheduled and nonscheduled caste sutdents. Indian Psychological Review20(4), 43-46.

Grindle, Christopher Carl (2009). An analysis of court cases involving student due process in dismissal from higher education. Ph.D. Dissertation, The University of Alabama.