英國教育史家B. Simon與綜合中學改革運動（1946-1990）
B. Simon and Comprehensive Education Movement (1946-1990)
- 關鍵字：
- B. Simon、智力測驗、意識型態、新右派、綜合中學 / B. Simon, intelligence testing, ideology, the New Right, comprehensive school
第六十七輯．第四期 - 2021-12-31
編輯的話卯靜儒
Words from the EditoralChin-Ju Mao
再思考教育關係：源起、意義與挑戰林建福
Rethinking Pedagogical Relation: Origins, Meanings and ChallengesChien-Fu Lin
操作型教師研習的網絡效果：行動者網絡理論視角陳斐卿
The Network Effect of In-service Teachers’ Hands-on Workshop: A View from Actor-Network TheoryFei-Ching Chen
英國教育史家B. Simon與綜合中學改革運動（1946-1990）顧曉雲
B. Simon and Comprehensive Education Movement (1946-1990)Hsiao-Yuh Ku
書評：評介《挑戰北京的天命：台灣的太陽花運動與香港雨傘運動》詹盛如
Book Review: Challenging Beijing’s Mandate of Heaven: Taiwan’s Sunflower Movement and Hong Kong Umbrella MovementSheng-Ju Chan
- 摘要
- 英文摘要
- 參考文獻
- 全文下載
B. Simon（1915-2002）是英國馬克思主義教育史家，也是第二次世界大戰結束以來綜合中學改革運動的先驅。本文聚焦於Simon在1946∼1990年間，為了提倡綜合中學所持續進行的意識型態批判，也藉此揭露Simon在此運動中所做的獨特貢獻。研究發現，Simon於1950、1960年代，立基於馬克思主義的「可教育性」理念以及蘇聯教育心理學的研究成果，批判智力測驗的理論和實踐。Simon也於1970年代批判進步／左派的教育理論（無政府主義／自由主義與「非學校化運動」、新馬克思主義、語言不利理論和文化相對主義），這些理論威脅綜合中學的發展。1970年代中期至1980年代，Simon更致力於批判新右派的教育政策，揭露其背後隱含的意識型態，分析這些政策如何阻撓綜合中學制度的建立。文末，筆者也試著從Simon的綜合中學教育理念出發，省思我國在十二年國民基本教育的推動下，後期中等教育學制面的可能改革方向。
B. Simon (1915-2002), a Marxist historian in England, was a pioneer in comprehensive education movement after the Second World War. This paper especially focuses on Simon’s critique of ideology between 1946 and 1990, through which he could effectively advocate for the comprehensive school. In so doing, the current work can uncover Simon’s effort and specific contribution to the movement. As the evidence shows, in the 1950s and 1960s, based on the Marxist ideal of “educability” and Soviet psychology of education, Simon criticized the theory and practice of intelligence testing. In 1970s, Simon also critically remarked on some contemporary theories put forward by progressive/left intellectuals, such as anarchist/libertarian ideas and the deschooling movement, neo-Marxism, as well as the theory of linguistic deprivation and relativist positions. All this threatened the development of comprehensive schools. From the mid-1970s and 1980s, Simon was also involved in criticizing the New Right’s educational policies. He revealed the ideology underlying these policies and analyzed how they obstructed the establishment of a comprehensive education system. On the basis of Simon’s ideal of comprehensive education, the author also reflects on the organization of upper secondary education in Taiwan under the scheme of twelve-year basic education.
李然堯（2013）。因應十二年國教，綜合高中如何適從。景文學報，23（2），143-164。
[Lee, J.-Y. (2013). How comprehensive high schools should involve in response to twelve-years
compulsory education. Jin-Wen Institute of Technology, 23(2), 143-164.]
周愚文（2008）。英國教育史：近代篇（1780-1944）。臺北市：學富。
[Chou, Y.-W. (2008). History of education in Britain 1780-1944. Taipei, Taiwan: Pro-Ed.]
教育部（2017）。十二年國民基本教育實施計畫。臺北市：作者。
[Ministry of Education. (2017). Plans for the 12-year basic education. Taipei, Taiwan: Author.]
鄭玉卿（1999）。學校教育制度的變革—反學校教育思潮的三種類型。初等教育學刊，7，129-153。
[Cheng, Y.-C. (1999). The transform of schooling system: Three types in the anti-schooling doctrine.
Journal of Elementary Education, 7, 129-153.]
譚光鼎（1998）。社會與文化再製理論之評析。教育研究集刊，40，23-50。
[Tan, G.-D. (1998). A critical analysis of theories of social and cultural reproduction. Bulletin of Educational
Research, 40, 23-50.]
譚光鼎（2010）。教育社會學。臺北市：學富。
[Tan, G.-D. (2010). Sociology of education. Taipei, Taiwan: Pro-Ed.]
Anonymous (1954a). Newbooks: A case to answer. Times Educational Supplement, 15 January (Simon
1/70). Simon Papers. IOE UCL Archives, London, UK.
Anonymous (1954b). Higher Education Journal, Spring 1954 (Simon 1/70). Simon Papers. IOE UCL
Archives, London, UK.
Anonymous (1975). 730 Keep the red flag flying. Times Educational Supplement, 25 July (Simon 3/3).
Simon Papers. IOE UCL Archives, London, UK.
Bailey, E. C. (2016). The development of the city technology college programms: 1980s Conservative ideas
about English secondary education (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). London School of
Economics and Political Science, London, UK.
Boyson, B. (1975). The developing case for the educational voucher. In C. B. Cox & R. Boyson (Eds.), Black
paper 1975: The fight for education (pp. 27-28). London, UK: J. M. Dent & Sons.
Brehony, K. J. (2004). Education as a “social function”: Sociology, and social theory in the histories of
Brian Simon. History of Education, 33(5), 545-558.
Chitty, C. (1989). Towards a new education system: The victory of the New Right?. Sussex, UK: The Flamer
Press.
Communist Party. (1962). Minutes of meeting held on 13 July 1962 (CP/CENT/CULT/1/5). Communist
Party’s Paper. People’s History Museum Archives, Manchester, UK.
Depaepe, M. (2004). It’s a long way to ... an international social history of education: In search of Brian
Simon’s legacy in today’s educational historiography. History of Education, 33(5), 531-544.
Department of Education and Science. (1970). The organization of secondary education (Circular 10/70).
London, UK: HMSO.
Department of Education and Science. (1974). The organization of secondary education (Circular 4/74).
London, UK: HMSO.
Department of Education and Science. (1975). The direct grant grammar schools regulation. London, UK:
HMSO.
Department of Education and Science. (1976). 1976 Education Act. London, UK: HMSO.
Department of Education and Science. (1986). A new choice of school. London, UK: HMSO.
Department of Education and Science. (1987a). Financial delegation to schools. London, UK: HMSO.
Department of Education and Science. (1987b). Admission of pupils to maintained schools. London, UK:
HMSO.
Department of Education and Science. (1987c). Grant maintained schools. London, UK: HMSO.
Department of Education and Science. (1987d). The national curriculum 5-16. London, UK: HMSO.
Department of Education and Science. (1987e). Education Reform Bill. London, UK: HMSO.
Department of Education and Science. (1988). Education Reform Act 1988. London, UK: HMSO.
Fry, G. K. (2008). The politics of the Thatcher revolution: An interpretation of British politics, 1979-1990.
New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.
Griggs, C. (1989). The New Right and English secondary education. In R. Lowe (Ed.), The changing
secondary school (pp. 99-128). London, UK: The Falmer Press.
John-Stevas, N. (1974). Standards and freedom. London, UK: Conservative Political Centre.
Jones, D. [ca. 2002]. Brian Simon: The indefatigable campaigner (A tribute to Brian Simon) (Simon 7/19).
Simon Papers. IOE UCL Archives, London, UK.
Jones, K. (2003). Education in Britain: 1944 to the present. Cambridge, UK: Polity.
Kavanagh, M. R. (2005). British communism and the politics of education, 1926-1968
(Unpublished doctoral dissertation). University of Manchester, Manchester, UK.
Knight, C. (1990). The making of Tory education policy in post-war Britain 1950-1986. London, UK: The
Flamer Press.
Ku, H. Y. (2021a). Ideological struggle in education: Brian Simon and comprehensive education movement
(1946-1965). History of Education. Retrieved from https://www.tandfonline. com/doi/
full/10.1080/0046766X.2021.1924876
Ku, H. Y. (2021b). Defending Comprehensive Education: Brian Simon and the Conservative Governments
(1979-1990). British Journal of Educational Studies. Retrieved from https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/
abs/10.1080/0071005.2021.1965084
Levitas, R. (1986). Introduction: Ideology and the New Right. In R. Levitas (Ed.), The ideology of the New
Right (pp. 1-24). Cambridge, UK: Polity.
McCulloch, G. (2002). Local education authorities and the organization of secondary education,
1943-1950. Oxford Review of Education, 28(2&3), 235-246.
McCulloch, G. (2010). A people’s history of education: Brian Simon, the British Communist Party and
studies in the history of education, 1780-1870. History of Education, 39(4), 437- 457.
McCulloch, G., & Woodin, T. (2010). Learning and liberal education: The case of the Simon family, 1912-19
39. Oxford Review of Education, 36(2), 187-201.
McLeish, J. (1975). Soviet psychology: History, theory, content. London, UK: Methuen & Co.
Morris, M. (1950). Intelligence testing – A class theory and practice. Communist Review, August, 238-243.
Morris, M., Searle, C., & Chitty, C. (2002). Brian Simon 1915-2002: An appreciation of his life and work
(Simon 8/19). Education for Tomorrow: For the Defence of State Education, 74, 7-9. Simon Papers.
IOE UCL Archives, London, UK.
Parsons, S. (1997). British Communist Party school teachers in the 1940s and 1950s. Science & Society,
Spring, 46-67.
Peden, G. C. (1991) British economic and social policy: Lloyd George to Margaret Thatcher. London, UK:
Philip Allan.
Perry, P. (1988). Book review on bending the rules. British Journal of Sociology of Education, 9(4), 480-484.
Rubinstein, D., & Simon, B. (1973). The evolution of the comprehensive school, 1926-1972 (2nd ed.).
London, UK: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Simon, B. (1949a). The theory and practice of intelligence testing. Communist Review, October, 687-695.
Simon, B. (1949b). Science and pseudo-science in psychology. The Educational Bulletin, 2(1), 11-12.
Simon, B. (1951). Ideological struggle in education, June 1951 (Simon 4/6/36). Simon Papers. IOE UCL
Archives, London, UK.
Simon, B. [n.d. 1951/2?] [ca. 1951/2]. Education: Ruling class strategy or tactics (Simon 1/44). Simon
Papers. IOE UCL Archives, London, UK.
Simon, B. (1954). Are children equal. Education Today, 6(6), 10, 12.
Simon, B. (1955). Some aspects of research in educational psychology in the USSR (Simon 1/58). SCR
Soviet Education Bulletin, 2(4), 49-68. Simon Papers. IOE UCL Archives, London, UK.
Simon, B. (1957a). Introduction. In B. Simon (Ed.), Psychology in the Soviet Union (pp. 1-27). London, UK:
Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Simon, B. (1957b). Education and psychology. Glasgow, February (Simon 1/4). Simon Papers. IOE UCL
Archives, London, UK.
Simon, B. (1958). The psychology of learning (Simon 1/27). Simon Papers. IOE UCL Archives, London, UK.
Simon, B. [n.d. 1958/1959?] [ca. 1958/1959]. Psychology of learning (Simon 1/27). Simon Papers. IOE UCL
Archives, London, UK.
Simon, B. (1959). The need for a theory of learning: Psychological research and educational method
(Simon 1/27). Simon Papers. IOE UCL Archives, London, UK.
Simon, B. (1962a). A visit to Soviet psychologists. The Anglo-Soviet Journal, 23(1), 9-13.
Simon, B. (1962b). Education and psychology (Simon 1/59). Marxism Today, December, 367- 369. Simon
Papers. IOE UCL Archives, London, UK.
Simon, B. (1967). Education: The new perspective. Leicester, UK: Leicester University Press.
Simon, B. (1968). Marxism and education, January 1968 (Simon 1/36). Simon Papers. IOE UCL Archives,
London, UK.
Simon, B. (1970a). Speech made by Brian Simon to the “Battle for Educational Opportunity Conference”
(Simon 1/17). Simon Papers. IOE UCL Archives, London, UK.
Simon, B. (1970b). Opportunities for education—A matter of national survival. Morning Star, 13 July, 4
(Simon 1/6). Simon Papers. IOE UCL Archives, London, UK.
Simon, B. (1972a). ROSLA and de-schooling. Forum, 14(3), 69.
Simon, B. (1972b). Half way there, Glasgow EIS, March (Simon 1/43). Simon Papers. IOE UCL Archives,
London, UK.
Simon, B. (1974a). Schools can make a difference. Forum, 16(2), 35.
Simon, B. (1974b). The politics of education. Forum, 17(1), 2-3.
Simon, B. (1975). Educational backwoodsmen. Morning Star, 12 May, 4 (Simon 3/3). Simon Papers. IOE
UCL Archives, London, UK.
Simon, B. [n.d., 1975?] [ca. 1975]. Ideological questions in education (CP/CENT/CULT/4/6). Communist
Party’s Paper. People’s History Museum Archives, Manchester, UK.
Simon, B. (1976a). Contemporary problems in educational theory. Marxism Today, June, 169-177.
Simon, B. (1976b). IQ, selection, and the development of the comprehensive system (Simon 1/9). Simon
Papers. IOE UCL Archives, London, UK.
Simon, B. (1976c). What school is for (A first go, written on 28 December) (Simon 1/18). Simon Papers.
IOE UCL Archives, London, UK.
Simon, B. (1977a). Marx and the crisis in education (Simon 1/10). Marxism Today, July, 195- 205. Simon
Papers. IOE UCL Archives, London, UK.
Simon, B. (1977b). Education and social change: A Marxist perspective. Marxism Today, February, 36-44.
Simon, B. (1978a). Karl Marx and education. In B. Simon (Ed.), Intelligence, psychology and education: A
Marxist critique (pp. 177-199). London, UK: Lawrence & Wishart.
Simon, B. (1978b). Intelligence testing and the comprehensive school. In B. Simon (Ed.), Intelligence,
psychology and education: A Marxist critique (pp. 29-121). London, UK: Lawrence & Wishart.
Simon, B. (1978c). Psychology and education. In B. Simon (Ed.), Intelligence, psychology and education: A
Marxist critique (pp. 125-138). London, UK: Lawrence & Wishart.
Simon, B. (1978d). Some contributions of Soviet psychology to the understanding of the learner. In B.
Simon (Ed.), Intelligence, psychology and education: A Marxist critique (pp. 139- 151). London, UK:
Lawrence & Wishart.
Simon, B. (1978e). Classification and streaming: A study of grouping in English schools 1860- 1960. In B.
Simon (Ed.), Intelligence, psychology and education: A Marxist critique (pp. 200-236). London, UK:
Lawrence & Wishart.
Simon, B. (1978f). Problems in contemporary educational theory: A Marxist approach. Journal of
Philosophy of Education, 12, 29-39.
Simon, B. (1978g). Education! The socialist perspective, May 1978 (Simon 1/41). Simon Papers. IOE UCL
Archives, London, UK.
Simon, B. (1978h). The education of the intellect, Warwick University, 9 May (Simon 1/5). Simon Papers.
IOE UCL Archives, London, UK.
Simon, B. (1980). Community and curriculum, 11-13 April (Simon 1/56). Simon Papers. IOE UCL Archives,
London, UK.
Simon, B. (1988a). Bending the rules: The Baker “reform” of education. London, UK: Lawrence &
Wishart.
Simon, B. (1988b). The education “reform” bill (for Communist Party) (Simon 1/23). Simon Papers. IOE
UCL Archives, London, UK.
Simon, B. (1991). Education and the social order, 1940-1990. London, UK: Lawrence & Wishart.
Simon, B. (1992a). Lessons in elitism. In B. Simon (Ed.), What future for education? (pp. 15- 33). London,
UK: Lawrence & Wishart.
Simon, B. (1992b). Maintaining progress towards a fully comprehensive system. In B. Simon (Ed.), What
future for education? (pp. 34-55). London, UK: Lawrence & Wishart.
Simon, B. (1992c). The politics of comprehensive reorganization: A retrospective analysis. History of
Education, 21(4), 355-362.
Simon, B. [n.d. 1993?] [ca. 1993]. Autobiography, Vol. II (1945-1994) (Simon 4/5/2/16). Simon Papers. IOE
UCL Archives, London, UK.
Simon, B. (1998). A life in education. London, UK: Lawrence & Wishart.
Simon, B., & Godden, C. (1978). The comprehensive school, March (CP/CENT/IND/10/2). Communist
Party’s Paper. People’s History Museum Archives, Manchester, UK.
Simon, B., & Simon, J. (1962). Soviet psychology and the west. Marxism Today, March, 80-87.
Solo, R. (1978). The neo-Marxist theory of the state. Journal of Economic Issues, 12(4), 829- 842.
Thom, D. (1986). The 1944 education act: The “art of the possible”?. In H. L. Smith (Ed.), War and social
change (pp. 101-128). Manchester, UK: Manchester University Press.
Thom, D. (2004). Politics and the people: Brian Simon and the campaign against intelligence tests in
British schools. History of Education, 33(5), 515-529.
Vernon, P. E. (1954). Book review on intelligence testing and the comprehensive school (Simon 1/70).
British Journal of Psychology, Summer. Simon Papers. IOE UCL Archives, London, UK.
Young, M. F. D. (1971a). Introduction. In M. F. D. Young (Ed.), Knowledge and control (pp. 1-17). London,
UK: Collier-Macmillan.
Young, M. F. D. (1971b). An approach to the study of curricula as socially organized knowledge. In M. F. D.
Young (Ed.), Knowledge and control (pp. 19-46). London, UK: Collier-Macmillan.
